Stone Resin vs Acrylic Shower Trays: A Comparison Guide
Choosing the right shower tray is crucial for both the functionality and aesthetics of your bathroom. Two of the most common materials used for shower trays are stone resin and acrylic, both of which offer unique benefits and drawbacks.
To help you make the right choice, in this article, we’re going to cover:
- The pros, and cons of each shower tray
- Their key differences, including durability, weight, heat retention, and cost
- Circumstances where one shower tray is more suitable than the other
But before we cover any of the above in more detail, we’d first like to explain what shower trays are and why they matter.
What Are Shower Trays and Why Do They Matter?
A shower tray is the foundation of your shower, designed to contain water and direct it toward the drain. Beyond their functional role in preventing leaks and water damage, shower trays also influence the style and comfort of your bathroom.
When designing a bathroom, many homeowners find themselves choosing between a shower tray and tiles. After careful consideration, most people pick a shower tray, and it’s easy to see why.
The right shower tray ensures proper drainage, enhances safety, and complements the overall aesthetic of the space (among many other benefits that we will talk about later in this blog). Two of the most popular choices are stone resin and acrylic. Both have distinct characteristics that impact performance, durability, and ease of maintenance.
What Is a Stone Resin Shower Tray?
A stone resin shower tray is made from a combination of crushed stone and resin, creating a dense, solid base. This results in a highly durable and sturdy shower tray with a premium feel.
Pros of Stone Resin Shower Trays
- Exceptional Durability: Resistant to cracks, chips, and wear over time.
- Premium Feel: Offers a solid, high-end finish that enhances the bathroom’s look.
- Better Heat Retention: Feels warmer underfoot compared to acrylic trays.
- Stable and Secure: The heavier weight prevents movement or shifting.
- Variety of Finishes: Available in matte or textured options for a stylish touch.
Cons of Stone Resin Shower Trays
- Heavy and Difficult to Install: Requires additional support and may need professional installation.
- Higher Cost: More expensive than acrylic options due to premium materials.
- Longer Heating Time: While it retains heat well, it can feel cold initially.
What Is an Acrylic Shower Tray?
An acrylic shower tray is made from lightweight acrylic reinforced with fiberglass for added strength. These trays are budget-friendly and widely used in modern bathrooms.
Pros of Acrylic Shower Trays
- Lightweight and Easy to Install: Can be installed without additional structural support.
- Cost-Effective: Generally more affordable than stone resin options.
- Available in Various Shapes and Sizes: Easily adaptable to different bathroom layouts.
- Resistant to Stains and Discoloration: Maintains its appearance with minimal upkeep.
Cons of Acrylic Shower Trays
- Less Durable: More prone to scratches, dents, and general wear over time.
- Can Feel Less Stable: Lower-quality models may flex slightly under weight.
- Shorter Lifespan: Typically do not last as long as stone resin trays.
Key Differences Between Stone Resin and Acrylic Shower Trays
There are a number of key differences between stone resin and acrylic shower trays. The biggest differences include:
Durability and Longevity
Stone resin shower trays are significantly more durable than acrylic ones. Their solid construction makes them highly resistant to cracks and wear, offering a longer lifespan. Acrylic trays, while sturdy, are more prone to scratches and can become discoloured over time. If longevity is a priority, stone resin is the better choice.
Weight and Installation
Weight plays a major role in installation complexity. Stone resin trays are much heavier, requiring proper structural support and often needing professional installation. This is especially true if you want to upgrade your shower with a spacious tray rather than a standard-sized one.
In contrast, acrylic trays are lightweight and easier to handle, making them a practical choice for DIY installations or renovations where floor reinforcement isn’t possible.
Appearance and Design Options
Both materials offer modern designs, but stone resin provides a more luxurious look and feel. Many stone resin trays come in matte or textured finishes that add to their premium aesthetic. Acrylic trays, while available in various colours and styles, often have a glossy, plastic-like appearance that may not suit all design preferences.
Heat Retention and Comfort
Stone resin trays excel in heat retention, meaning they stay warmer for longer once heated. However, they can feel cold initially. Acrylic trays, on the other hand, feel warmer to the touch immediately, offering better comfort from the start. If warmth underfoot is a key concern, acrylic trays may be more appealing.
Maintenance and Cleaning
Acrylic trays are easier to clean as they have a smooth, non-porous surface that resists stains and buildup. However, they can scratch more easily, requiring gentle cleaning methods. Stone resin trays are also relatively low-maintenance but may need occasional resealing to maintain their finish, especially if they have a textured surface.
Cost Comparison
If budget is a deciding factor, acrylic shower trays are the more affordable choice. They are widely available and have lower installation costs. Stone resin trays, while more expensive, offer better durability and a premium feel that can be worth the investment in high-end bathroom designs.
Which Shower Tray Is Right for You?
The best shower tray depends on your bathroom needs, budget, and preferences. Here are a couple of circumstances that would make one shower tray more suitable than the other:
- If you want maximum durability, a premium feel, and excellent heat retention, a stone resin shower tray is the best option.
- If you prefer a lightweight, cost-effective, and easy-to-install solution, an acrylic shower tray is the better choice.
For modern, high-end bathroom designs, stone resin provides a more luxurious aesthetic. - For renovations or budget-friendly updates, acrylic offers convenience and affordability.
Final Thoughts
Both stone resin and acrylic shower trays come with distinct advantages, so it's essential to weigh their pros and cons based on your specific needs.
Stone resin trays offer unmatched durability, stability, and a high-end finish, making them ideal for long-term use. Acrylic trays, however, provide cost-effectiveness, ease of installation, and immediate warmth, making them a practical choice for many homes.
By considering factors like installation, comfort, maintenance, and budget, you can confidently choose the shower tray that best suits your bathroom design and lifestyle.